A century ago, a New York surgeon developed a procedure called “simple,” or “open,” prostatectomy. He reached the prostate through the bladder and used his fingers to remove the overgrown tissue surrounding the urethra, leaving the rest of the prostate intact. (This is not the same thing as a radical prostatectomy, the removal of the entire prostate, which is often used to treat localized prostate cancer.) A refined version of this procedure, which surgeons call suprapubic prostatectomy, is still used today in a small percentage of men with BPH; so is a variation of it called simple retropubic prostatectomy.
But another form of prostatectomy, developed nearly fifty years ago, has eclipsed both operations and is now the main form of surgical treatment for BPH. In this procedure, called transurethral resection of the prostate (TUR; also called a TURP), surgeons reach the prostate by taking a different route— through the urethra. Unlike other forms of prostatectomy, this does not involve a long hospital stay; there’s no incision or scar, and the recovery time is shorter. One major benefit of the TUR—and all forms of prostatectomy—is the opportunity to check the prostate tissue that was removed for cancer after surgery.
The TUR is available to men who otherwise might not be eligible for surgery. About 95 percent of the prostatectomies performed in this country are done transurethrally. And despite the development of new techniques to relieve urinary obstruction, the TUR remains the gold standard for BPH treatment.
However, the TUR is not for everybody. For example, men with large prostates (with obstructive tissue that’s estimated to weigh more than seventy-five grams, or two and a half ounces) probably should have an open prostatectomy. So should some men with large diverticula of the bladder that need to be treated, or men with large bladder stones. (Diverticula are pockets of the bladder lining that poke out like balloons through the bladder wall.) If diverticula or bladder stones need to be removed, this procedure can be “piggybacked” onto (done at the same time as) an open prostatectomy—as surgical “one-stop shopping.”
Nor is the open prostatectomy ideal for every man. The average age of men who have a prostatectomy is 70; by this time in life, many men have other health problems that preclude open surgery—such as a history of heart or lung disease, diabetes, or high blood pressure. For most of these men, and for men with a small prostate, the TUR is the best option. The open prostatectomy is generally reserved for younger men, and those with very large prostates who are otherwise healthy and in good cardiovascular condition.
If your health is considered too precarious even for the TUR, there’s still help—a catheter can provide immediate relief of an overfull bladder, for example. Early studies show intraurethral stents to be a good option for long-term relief of symptoms. Also, you may be able to take medication to shrink the prostate.
*247\201\8*